Featured
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
The Intergenerational Swindle: How the West Devours Its Own Children — True Cannibalism
We no longer have the morality to say "enough." So we borrow. The numbers are known, the debts are public, and no one rises to ask who will pay. This article is not an economic indictment: it is the diagnosis of a society that has removed, one by one, every wall that once held human greed in check — and that now stares into the abyss, eyes wide open, with the satisfaction of those who understood too late.
Reading: (Easy, 1908 words, 8 to 10 min.)
The Intergenerational Swindle: How the West Devours Its Own Children — True Cannibalism
Introduction
Every society is the sum of its individuals. If the individual loses his morality, the society disintegrates. That is the sentence that condenses everything that follows, and it is through that lens that we must read the state of our civilizations.
We are living a paradox we refuse to face. The G7 countries are accumulating tens of trillions in debt. Every year they run deficits of hundreds of billions. And the overwhelming share of those deficits — over 80 percent — funds neither roads, nor research, nor infrastructure that the next generation would inherit: it funds current operations — pensions, salaries, benefits, interest. We have built a welfare state on the backs of children not yet born, and we do not care.
A few decades ago, a balanced budget was the norm. Not because technique demanded it more, but because an intergenerational morality still weighed on consciences: you do not pass on to your children a debt without an asset, any more than you pass on a mortgage without a house. That morality has disappeared. What remains is to understand why, and by what mechanism an entire society can, with open eyes, ruin those who will come after it.
The answer has a scientific name: anomie.
1. Anomie: the exact word for a society without limits
Coined by the philosopher Jean-Marie Guyau, it was Émile Durkheim, the father of modern sociology, who gave the concept its full power at the end of the nineteenth century. The word comes from the Greek a- (privative) and nomos (the rule, the law). It literally means the absence of norms. But Durkheim is not speaking of written laws: he is speaking of the collapse of the moral rules that bound human desires.
Durkheim begins from a simple and unsettling observation. The animal has limited needs: hunger stops when the stomach is full. Man, by contrast, has desires that are without natural limit. Nothing in his physical or psychological constitution indicates where his thirst for wealth, comfort, or status should stop. Hence the decisive sentence in Suicide (1897):
"If nothing external restrains our sensibility, it is in itself a bottomless abyss that nothing can fill."
And the consequence, clinical in its harshness:
"Unlimited desires are insatiable by definition. To pursue a goal that is by definition unattainable is to condemn oneself to a perpetual state of discontent."
In plain terms: the more we have, the more we want. Satisfactions received only stimulate needs instead of appeasing them. This is exactly what we observe every day — "I exist because I consume, and I consume because I compare myself" — but written in 1897 by a professor at the Sorbonne.
Durkheim's conclusion is capital:
"A regulative force must play the same role for moral needs that the organism plays for physical needs. Which is to say that this force must be moral."
The limit cannot come from the individual. It must come from the outside: from a shared morality, a tradition, a religion — a force that says "enough." When that force disappears without being replaced, man does not become free. He becomes unregulated. That is anomie: what Durkheim calls "the malady of the infinite."
2. The disturbing detail: abundance is as murderous as misery
Here we must correct a common misconception, because the exact version of Durkheim is harsher than the approximate one.
It is often believed that anomic suicide rises in times of crisis. That is true, but it is not the most interesting part. The title of Durkheim's chapter is more precise: suicide rises with economic crises, and this increase persists in crises of prosperity.
In other words: anomic suicide also rises during booms, during sudden enrichment, during rapid prosperity. Why? Because in both cases — ruin or enrichment — the markers that bounded desires shatter. The newly rich suffers from the same deregulation as the ruined man: his desires, suddenly without a ceiling, condemn him to dissatisfaction in the midst of his gold.
This destroys the classic objection that "we must keep spending to make people happy." Durkheim demonstrates the opposite: abundance without limits produces the same malaise as poverty. The problem is not the level of wealth. It is the absence of limits. A civilization that grows richer without recovering its limits does not find peace: it panics.
3. Anomie translated into public accounting
None of this is theory. The chronic public deficit is anomie translated into budgetary language.
The latest IMF projections (2026), gross public debt as a percentage of GDP:
| Country (G7) | Public debt (≈ % of GDP) |
|---|---|
| Japan | ~204% |
| Italy | ~138% |
| United States | ~126% |
| France | ~118% |
| Canada | ~111% |
| United Kingdom | ~100% |
| Germany | ~63% |
Six of the seven G7 countries therefore owe more than everything they produce in a year, and most of them borrow still more — every year — to pay for the cost of living today. We do not borrow to build; we borrow to consume.
This is the exact Durkheimian definition of deregulation: unlimited desires translated into finance laws. The anomic state is a state that can no longer tell itself "enough." It has lost every external regulating force, every moral limit, and lives in accounting denial of the consequences. The debt of our children is not a managerial accident: it is anomie measured in points of GDP.
4. A swindle, not an accident — and those who orchestrate it know it
Here we must name things. This transfer of wealth from future generations to the present is neither an accident, nor a technical complexity, nor a necessary evil. It is an intergenerational swindle, and it must be said with that vulgar word, because it is the only one that is accurate.
What is a swindle, in the precise sense? A victim who cannot consent, a good taken without counterpart, an opacity that conceals the extraction, and an immediate benefit for the swindler. All four conditions are met.
- The victim cannot consent. The generation of 2050 does not yet exist. It has no voice, no vote, no lawyer, no recourse. It is the ideal victim: absent and mute.
- The extraction is without counterpart. The deficit funds operations, consumption, spending burned — not assets the children will inherit. They will inherit only the debt, without the factory or the bridge that might correspond to it.
- The opacity is total, without being secret. Nobody hides the deficit; they drown it in billions, in percentages of GDP, in acronyms, in ten-year projections everyone knows are false. The swindler does not always lie: he counts on the fact that the victim has no time, no expertise, and above all no ability yet to pay.
- The benefit is immediate: votes.
This is where we must be unsparing, because this is the central point: politicians know exactly what they are doing.
When an elected official announces a spending measure without a corresponding revenue, he is not naïve, he is not "trapped by the system" in spite of himself. He makes a clear calculation: the gift is seen today, the bill will be paid later, the vote is won now. It is a conscious, deliberate act, repeated thousands of times, everywhere, for decades. He knows perfectly well that there is no money, that he is sending the spending into the deficit, and that this deficit will fall on people who do not vote.
This is not a conspiracy — a conspiracy implies secrecy, coordination, and the intent to harm, and none of that exists here. There is something worse: a million individual betrayals, each perfectly conscious, each calculated to win votes today, each knowing very well that it sends the bill to people not yet born.
And the system does not merely permit this act. It makes it obligatory, and it punishes virtue. What becomes of the honest official who says, "there is no money, I refuse this gift"? The candidate across the aisle promises the same spending without funding it. He wins. The virtuous official disappears. Repeat this cycle for forty years, and you get a political class in which not a single honest survivor remains — not because they were eliminated, but because the electoral calculation mathematically eliminates those who do not promise what they do not have.
And the voter himself is complicit. At bottom, he asks to be lied to, because he wants the gift without the tax. The politician is neither a saint nor a monster: he is a rational actor who maximizes his votes, exactly as the entrepreneur maximizes his profit. In a system where unfunded spending wins votes, it is irresponsibility that is rational, not virtue.
5. Why nothing replaces morality: the counterexamples that confirm the rule
One might object: if all the safeguards have been removed, why do some countries remain in balance? The answer completes the demonstration, because it shows that discipline never rested on human goodness, but on the presence of an effective sanction.
- Switzerland (~40% of GDP in debt) replaced the fear of God with a secular fear: the referendum. The taxpayer votes directly on what he will pay. The sanction is immediate, democratic, cold — and it works like the morality of old. Switzerland has not recovered religion; it has re-established a sanction.
- Germany wrote a debt brake into its Constitution in 2009: a limit, literally a rule, imposed from the outside on the state's budgetary desires.
- Russia (~19% of debt) is not "virtuous": it is constrained by the trauma of the 1998 default, by energy rents, and by geopolitical fear. Its discipline is a discipline of survival, not of morality.
These three cases converge on a single law, which is precisely Durkheim's: what maintains balance is not the goodness of men, but the presence of an external force that bounds their desires. The indebted West is not more wicked than Switzerland. It is anomic: it has lost God, shame, and tradition — and it has put nothing in their place.
We must be honest here. Durkheim was agnostic. He never preached a return to Christianity. His diagnosis is ours — traditional morality has dissolved — but his solution is the opposite of a restoration: society itself must produce new limits. One can do without God. One cannot do without any limit at all. The question is not metaphysical. It is regulatory.
5 bis — History is a graveyard of empires that died for refusing to cut the insolvent privilege
If proof is needed that this diagnosis is not conjectural, one need only look at history. It is mechanically regular, and that is precisely what is terrifying: no empire died for lack of means. All of them died for refusing to say "no" to those who extracted more than the base could produce.
The insolvent privilege is this: an acquired right, a rent, a benefit, or a way of life that the community can no longer afford, but that no one dares to cut — because those who benefit from it are precisely those who hold the power to oppose the reduction.
Let us look at the sequence, for it almost never varies.
Rome was not defeated by the barbarians. It was ruined from within. The Roman political class refused to tax the great landowners, who were precisely those who sustained it. To finance bread and circuses — panem et circenses — without touching those fortunes, the Empire diluted its currency century after century: the silver of the argenteus melted away, and confidence with it. When the army became too expensive and the tax too insufficient, the Empire ended by summoning the barbarians as mercenaries to defend a state that no longer paid for itself. The fall did not come from a military defeat. It came from the inability to cut the privileges of its own elite.
Habsburg Spain, the world's first power in the sixteenth century, was overflowing with the gold and silver of America. It drew from it enough to sterilize its own economy: the gold was never used to invest, but to pay the court, the wars, and the pensions. Spain defaulted five times between 1557 and 1627. It preferred present splendor to the inheritance of future generations, and it passed from empire to the periphery of Europe without ever losing a decisive battle. It simply exhausted what it refused to reduce.
France of the Ancien Régime did not fall because the people were poor — they always had been. It fell because the monarchy was incapable of taxing the privileged orders, the nobility and the clergy, who held the wealth while being exempt from most of the tax. Calonne's fiscal reform, in 1786, failed precisely because it touched those insolvent privileges. The rest is known: those who then refused to yield a little were forced, a few years later, to yield everything — and much more.
The Ottoman Empire stagnated and then declined while protecting its privileged militias, the janissaries, who had become a parasitic caste. The sultans, who depended on them to hold the throne, dared neither pay them properly nor reform them. The elite corps became an extraction corps, resistant to any modernization, which the state finally had to dissolve in blood in 1826 — too late to save the Empire from its decline.
The pattern is identical everywhere, in every age and under every sky:
An elite or a mass organizes its extraction of wealth beyond what the base can produce, refuses any reduction of that extraction, and the entity dies of internal exhaustion.
The name of this process is not war; it is liquidation. Spengler called it Untergang, the decline, and he made one decisive point: decline is not a sudden catastrophe; it is a process spread over several generations, in which everyone, at every stage, finds an excellent reason to change nothing.
And here we must measure the gravity of our own situation. Our modern democracies have pushed this mechanism to its paroxysm, because they have institutionalized the insolvent privilege by renaming it "acquired rights." What Rome, Spain, or monarchical France had to extract from a reluctant elite, our states now vote into law themselves, every year, in open session, in the name of the majority — sending the bill to people not yet born.
The old empires at least refused to admit their weakness. We have elevated it into a rule of law. The insolvent privilege is no longer the preserve of a caste: it has become the common patrimony, claimed by all, financed by the deficit, and guaranteed by law. It is the first time in history that a civilization organizes, democratically and freely, the liquidation of its own children — and calls it "social justice."
6. The root cause: society is the sum of its individuals
Everything comes back to man. This is the opening sentence, and it is the conclusion.
Society is not a separate being hovering above men. It is men — their habits, their restraint, their shame, their duties. When those restraints die in each chest, no "society" remains above: only a crowd organized by fear and by law.
Morality is not what makes a society "better." It is what makes it possible. The trust that a contract will be honored — that is morality. The restraint not to cheat when no one is watching — that is morality. The sense of duty to pay one's taxes without supervision — that is morality. The shame of ruining one's children for one's own comfort — that is morality. Remove all that, and nothing remains between individuals but brute force — law, police, surveillance, courts.
And here the loop closes on the deficit: what morality once did for free, out of duty or shame, the state must now buy at great cost. Managing rampant delinquency, filling the absence of fathers, treating the diseases of opulence and loneliness, caring for abandoned elders: all of this was once done out of love or duty, within the family and the community. Today it has been handed to the state — and it is borrowed, because no one wants to pay for it.
The massive deficit is not a managerial accident. It is the replacement cost of a morality that no longer works for free. It is the trace, written at the bottom of the page, of a man who has ceased to feel responsible for the one who will come after him.
Conclusion
Man is greedy. That is not an opinion; it is a constant of every century ever observed. What has changed is not man: it is the walls that had been built around his greed to render it harmless — the fear of God, shame before the community, the transmission of patrimony, balance as a moral norm. We have removed them, one by one, believing we were emancipating ourselves. We did not free man: we freed his predation.
And predation, left to itself, obeys a single logic: take today, always more, never reduce. That is exactly how all the empires before us died. The moral walls have fallen; the sanction has disappeared; and the process now unfolds in broad daylight, voted year after year by the very people who profit from it.
We know what would have to be done. It would require millions of men, each in his private life, to accept reducing a present advantage for a distant and invisible duty. That is exactly what morality once produced — and exactly what a society that has killed morality has become incapable of producing. We are therefore not facing a problem of means, but a problem of will. And the will to deprive oneself for people not yet born — no society has ever managed to summon it by decree.
So the question is no longer whether we will pay. History says we always pay. The only question is who will choose the deadline and the apportionment: our creditors, our children, or the events. And everything indicates it will not be us, because we are already refusing — with the quiet satisfaction of those who will have been right too late.
Empires do not die for lack of means. They die for lack of the will to reduce what is no longer sustainable. This is not a prophecy. It is a reading. And ours is already written in the account books we bequeath to men who do not yet have a name.
We have no conqueror to accuse. The barbarians are not at the gates: they are at the table.
References
Émile Durkheim, Suicide: A Study in Sociology, Paris, Félix Alcan, 1897.
- Book II, Chapter V: "Anomic Suicide" — source of all Durkheim quotations in sections 1 and 2, in particular on the "malady of the infinite," unlimited desires, and the role of the moral regulating force.
- Book III — on the chronic state of anomie in the economic world and the need for moral regulation.
International Monetary Fund, World Economic Outlook, April 2026 projections — gross general government debt as a percentage of GDP (table in section 3).
For the historical examples (section 5 bis):
- Edward Gibbon, The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire (1776–1789) — on currency dilution and the fiscal crisis of the late Empire.
- Fernand Braudel, The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean World in the Age of Philip II (1949) — on the successive defaults of Habsburg Spain.
- Alexis de Tocqueville, The Old Regime and the Revolution (1856) — on the failure of fiscal reform in the face of privilege.
- Oswald Spengler, The Decline of the West (1918–1922) — on the concept of Untergang and decline as a drawn-out process rather than a catastrophe.
Popular Posts
The 250-Year Cycle: Why ALL Empires Collapse at the Same Point
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Wake Up Before the Fuse Reaches the End
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Comments
Post a Comment